Quote:
Originally Posted by trace87
Good News was my introduction to Modest Mouse. I mean it has its moments but for me is kinda hollow. It has this kinda fake feel to me. Like Brock is trying SOOO hard to keep his edge intact while having this super polished sound that was a continuation from The Moon & Antarctica(first album with major label). The album has it's successes, but it is certainly not without its share of failures too.
|
I pretty much agree with this (except it wasn't my introduction). The only songs on
Good News... that I actually like are Ocean Breathes Salty, Bury Me With It, Bukowski, Satin in a Coffin, Black Cadillacs. Well ok that's almost half, but it's not like I love them either. The rest I either can't stand or they feel like filler, so overall I don't like the album. Some of the singing is downright cringe-worthy (though not as bad as the following album...it was just a preview of what was to come), and tracks like "The Good Times are Killing Me" really sum it up nicely...more like "this f
ucking album is killing me" by the time that comes around.
Yes, harsh words for a band I used to love. As I've said before, what it comes down to for me is a loss of sincerity in the sound.