Jack, you really should give them a listen. Yes, they definitely changed slowly over time after Fish left (I'd say we saw the last real echoes of the Big Yin in "Season's end" and "Holidays in Eden", possibly resurfacing in "Brave"), and they are now a different band, but they're making some great music! Your loyalty to Fish is commendable, but I have never understood why some people have to choose: I love old Marillion, Fish solo and new Marillion -- I get the best of both worlds!