Quote:
Originally Posted by jackhammer
We will let BooBoo describe the criteria for his choices. As I have already said lists are always subjective.I am a little nonplussed myself as to certain inclusions but let's wait for his take on it please.
|
Creativity, Originality, Influence, Status, Impact, to a lesser extent Technical Skill and just my personal bias.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sodacake
I don't think Holdsworth is rock enough for this list.
|
He's played for progressive rock groups like Soft Machine and Gong, in fact he's collaborated with a lot of rock musicians on what are basically rock recordings, and enough of his own solo material could be considered rock. I dont really think of him as a pure jazz guitarist, and most purists would agree to that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Urban Hatemonger
No Michael Karoli or Graham Coxon or did I miss them ?
I have to say i'm surprised by the inclusion of Glen Buxton. Did you know he didn't record anything with Alice Cooper after Schools Out?
|
I am aware of that. But Live it to Death and Schools Out are considered milestones in his career, he did much to define Coopers original sound.
Maybe he's too high, but I'm not gonna worry about the rankings too much, just the inclusions more than anything.
EDIT: Made one slight change, replaced Homme with Ace Frehley. But I dont intend to make any more changes, I like the final result just fine and I'm not trying to please anyone, just curious what people have to say.