Quote:
Originally Posted by mr dave
you're first half is fair, you're second half is not.
i don't think you'll find anyone to argue against music in modern society being about personal expression (although on this site there might be some who would just for spite).
but your 2nd statement is bogus. it seems you're implying the purpose of music is to promote personal expression AND christianity and should not be separated.
no one here has said religion couldn't be part of music, only that within modern contexts it usually sucks - A LOT. it's only really been the last century or two that music for the masses has truly become secular in an overwhelming fashion. but i really believe the switch from sacred to secular has far more to do with advancements in technology than anything else.
i think crowquill nails it as far as why average people in today's society don't bother with religious music. it's lame formulaic dreck that fails to distract from the ham fisted sermonizing posturing as lyrics.
|
Sorry, I wasn't clear with the second one. I meant that alienating any subject, Christianity or otherwise, from music contradicts the purpose of music, which is to express yourself through melodic or harmonic sounds. I just used Christianity since that is what this thread is about.
I honestly don't know too many Christian bands, metal or otherwise. I guess the closest ones I can think of are probably Devil Wears Prada and Norma Jean (If you guys consider them Christan bands). They're alright to me, but my god they suck live. Saw the former at Sounds of the Underground last year and was glad I walked in at the end of their set.