Originally Posted by right-track

I'm gonna disagree.
First and foremost, yes this is a music forum, but the attached non music forums seem to attract new members and help keep the current members posting here on MusicBanter.
The 'Arcade' being the case in point.

I really can't see what harm a 'Creative Forum' can cause. After all, quite a few of the members who post here may have initially been attracted by the 'Songwriting' forum, which I agree is music related, but without it would the likes of hobojesus, DRMO, crow etc choose to stay?
I'm sure a 'Creative Forum' would prove popular among those members just mentioned, amongst others.
It sounds like a good idea and at least should be given a try.