Quote:
Originally Posted by Spectralmusic
Though Carter (like the serialists) often falls into the category of being too romantic, so it looses that edge.
|
I don't think that's a fair criticism of Carter. I assume you intentionally used a lowercase r romantic. I get that it's a bit off topic but I think you could just as easily say that the composers you're favoring use extreme dissonance as a crutch. That's certainly NOT my opinion. I'm just pointing out they Carter fills a very important place in the 20th C. Different composers brought different elements to the table. Carter's music is dissonant and lyrical and definitely very important.