Quote:
Originally Posted by elphenor
I don't really see how they're comparable to Nickleback or Oasis at all
I don't see what point those comparisons make other than "here is a band I think sucks, now here is another band I think sucks"
|
Except that they both took genres before them and watered them down to make music palatable to the greater masses. Especially Oasis.
Quote:
Originally Posted by elphenor
I think it's funny how current Corgan proved the indie hatred of SP in the 90's was valid only now in retrospective reviews you see mags giving SD and MCIS great scores
|
Pretty sure plenty of critics said the same things about them. Plenty of people in the know hated the band at the time.
Quote:
Originally Posted by elphenor
i mean most people like at least a couple pumpkins songs
|
Plenty of people also like at least a couple Nickelback songs. I like "Animals" and "Rockstar", and yet that doesn't make Nickelback a good band.