Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Charlie
I suspect Wpnfire was being sarcastic as meaning is entirely subjective.
With regards to flags serving as symbols, yes, that's true. But symbols ain't real. Two people see the same Swastika, one has knowledge of Nazism, one doesn't, to one it's a symbol, to the other it's only an image. Symbols cannot exist outside the mind. We choose, willingly or not, to give them power. If we empty our heads of pre-conceptions and associations, then an image is just an image, and we don't confuse harmless flags with heinous acts.
|
I don't know man. It just kind of feels like you're saying "look at me, I'm not affected by random shapes and colors". And while I'm sure it's true of Nazi nationalism that the flag doesn't offend you or cause you to go out on genocide, there still are symbols in your life that influence you based on what you grew up with and were exposed to and what your association cortex had to work with between visual signals and autobriographical memories.
But the main point is that regardless of how enlightened you may personally be, you must acknowledge that there's sufficient pockets of population that derive synergy from common ideals through the physical manifestations of symbolism. You may choose not to give them power, but they still give power to the people that unite under them. Of course, they're replaceable. If we take away one flag, they'll find another one or another symbol. So in that regard, it's a bit cat and mouse. However, what it does do when a nation enacts policies to reduce the public occurrence of a symbol, they're communicating that they don't like the thing that symbol stands for. And that's important, because people will feel more justified in behavior when authority figures condone of it. So the symbolism works both ways.
If you need evidence that's pretty thoroughly researched, look into branding. Branding is a commercial setting, so its a bit different because there's not much funding available to study nationalism and hate groups, compared to studying what makes people buy your product more (because of the disparity in monetary incentive).