Quote:
Originally Posted by Chula Vista
4'33 is a performance piece about the 'concept' of music. I'll give it props for that.
But in and of itself? It ain't music.
Lisnaholic's clip is music. Beautiful music.
|
Well, to be fair, 4'33" is pointing the lens at what's beyond the piece. So what of the noises outside of a performance of 4'33"? If they are rhythmic and sound cool, like what could (and, in my experience, has) happen(ed) in the early stages of that video, are they music?
EDIT: Forgive my Socratic method, I just feel it's the only way to convert you to the Church of Cage.