Quote:
Originally Posted by Janszoon
Well, how else are you going to judge them? That said, I do sort of see what you're saying. The band that always comes to mind when I think about this kind of thing is Limp Bizkit. I generally think they're a pretty terrible band, but also have always been convinced that Wes Borland and John Otto are both fairly talented guys who could possibly make some good music under different musical circumstances.
|
On the regard of Limb Bizkit. I have had the same opinion of Wes Borland and John Otto since I first started listening to them back when I was a wee young lad in middle school. Wes Borland is a fairly above average guitar player, but I wouldn't go much more past that. John Otto has a keen understand of good rhythm...other things too that I can't name, forgetful.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Urban Hat€monger ?
Musical 'talent' isn't the be all and end all of everything.
You could have all the musical chops in the world but if you have nothing worth saying and you're playing in a faceless boring generic rock band liked by nobody over the age of 15 then you kind of deserve to be there and you deserve to get criticism.
|
Eh, I don't know about that. Criticism will be given irregardless of having something to say, or having nothing to say, whether you've any musical aptitude, or none at all.