Hatemonger, you serious about Kingston? He's a great in-ring worker, makes other people look good, pulls off some cool moves and spots so is always a factor in a ladder/battle royal match. He does exciting things. Yes, his character is just a typical goofy good guy but he's not had the chance to add a layer of depth. I think he could surprise a few people if he gets the chance.
As for Sheamus, the guy's one of the best in-ring talents the company has. Hard hitting, athletic, strong, versatile and capable of working face or heel.
If anyone needs cut I'd go - Sin Cara, Matadors, Rosa Mendes, Gabriel, Kidd, Natalya, Khali, Rose and Darren Young.
@Overcast: You chose Crash Holly over The Rock or Stone Cold? What's wrong with you