Great review Rostasi (even if you didn't use the matrix I worked so hard on!)
and very detailed. You should be writing journals, hint hint! I think we decided on the following rating system though, just to keep everything relatively uniform:
Also a universal rating out of say 5, For example could be:
5.0- Masterpiece
4.5- Classic
4.0- Great
3.5- Good
3.0- Decent
2.5- Weak
2.0- Poor
1.5- Crap
1.0- Dud
If we're all happy with this I'd like to utilise this, so no ratings other than the ones shown here. If that's ok with everyone.