I'm surprised I'm the first to vote for making my own.
I like to do it kinda 50-50.
Well, 60-40 really. I'll do a good sized batch of crunchy peanut butter and a smaller batch of smooth and stir um together.
Also, as for alternative x-butters if anyone has a trader joe's near their home they really need to check this out:
Pretty much the food of the Gods right here.