Jeez Francis why is this even a thread?
I thought their new EP was very average. The only song that I thought was enjoyable was Indie Cindy but the other four tracks were poor by Pixies standards. I'm open to hearing new music from reformed bands (Dinosaur Jr released some great material since they reformed) but this EP was a big let down. It's nothing to do with them having a different sound or Kim Deal no longer being in the band or anything, they just sound average by both today's standards and compared to their old stuff.
So yep, old-school Pixies any day of the week.