I should also point out, this whole discussion on whether members should be allowed to accuse each other of trolling, is so, so, so far away from being anything useful.
1 - People aren't complete wankers. They're not going to call someone a troll unless the person is actively participating in a debate in such a way that they are both disruptive and questionably sincere. Specifically, in their opinion, which they must hold confidently enough to MAKE THE ACCUSATION, the belief must be there that the other party cannot possibly be serious.
That isn't a decision people jump to to invalidate another's position, it's a position people take because they HAVE ALREADY TRIED MANY TIMES TO RECONCILE THE OTHER PERSONS ARGUMENT WITH LOGIC.
Yes, people who are butt**** stupid will call the wrong people trolls, HOWEVER, if it is clear to people that the person is NOT a troll (IE, Me being accused), then a simple warning that the accusation is wrong can be made by anyone on the forum and will hold EQUAL if not greater weight, than if that warning was made pre-emptively.
2 - To say someone is trolling, you are not throwing out some internet buzzword nobody understands or can reconcile with its meaning - It's not like accusing someone of being "A brainwashed cryptofascist apologist", where people might have no idea what that is or means. To say someone is trolling is a shorthand for saying one very simple thing:
"I believe that you are insincere in this debate, and out to cause trouble by adopting a stance calculated to offend others".
(I'll give everyone exactly one guess to think of a member who does that ABSOLUTELY ALL THE DAMNED TIME.)
To try and put a ban on people taking that position is to completely doom ourselves to a forum where nobody can be accused of seeking to cause trouble. Where the only method of even having that position taken into account, is the report button, so that the mod team can assume all authority over whether the user fits the bill of "troll".
That's not discussion. That's not self governance and it's not going to help one little tiny bit. (Unless you're actually a troll, in which case you're pretty much by the letter of the law being protected against anyone who might point this fact out in any manner which isn't carefully and specifically worded).
All it would do, in fact, is turn normal, reasonable members, into the bad guy, for voicing their opinions of a controversial or disruptive member. And in the process, it would take attention away from the actual problem of said controversial or disruptive member - IN OTHER WORDS, it sends the mods on wild goose chases to stop people being errantly mean to each other, in order to safeguard any special snowflakes feelings being hurt by mean people on the internet.
And all the while the people who are actually the damned problem get to play victim.