I voted the 2nd one (on the right). Only listened to each one once, but the one on the right seemed to have a wee bit more dynamism, with a few more higher notes and wider range of notes than the on on the left.
EDIT: Correction: I still like the 2nd one better, but it's more because the last half of the piece was a little more interesting, not because it necessarily had a greater range of notes. 2nd half seemed more lively than the 2nd half of the piece on the left.
|