Nursery Cryme, Selling England by the Pound, and Foxtrot take it for me. SEBTP is the most consistent in my opinion, but I love "The Musical Box" and the hogweed song way too much to not vote Nursery Cryme as well. And of course, if Foxtrot only consisted of "Supper's Ready", and the rest of the album was Peter Gabriel miming, I'd still have it in my collection.
|