After having played through Amnesia, I'm still of the opinion that it doesn't quite live up to it's hype, but it's a fine game nonetheless. However, I felt more impressed when I played it's predecessor (though not in story) Penumbra : Black Plague.
I was thinking of getting the game Scratches because I read it's a horror first person point 'n click game which is also supposed to be rather good and spooky. A Director's Cut version is available both from
steam and
gog. So I've yet to play it, but maybe someone else here have played it and could comment?