Lisnaholic

This is a thread where anyone who has heard, or plans to hear this album is invited to post a comment :-

Counting from his self-titled 1968 debut album, Neil Young has released a total of something like fifty albums. If Massey Hall, recorded in front of a small, respectful audience in Toronto, had been released at the time, it would been his third album. Instead it`s actually his 42nd release, part of some complex ongoing archival series of a kind that only a few select artists attempt. ( Zappa, Phish, Dylan, the Allmans, the Dead and the Beatles are others that spring to mind.)
So, what`s your opinion of Massey Hall ? How does it stand up as an album ? How do the songs compare with the studio versions ? Which NY would you rather hear, the weary, rough-voiced stadium-filler of today or the fresh young troubador of forty years ago ?

__________________
"Am I enjoying this moment? I know of it and perhaps that is enough." - Sybille Bedford, 1953

SATCHMO

To be honest, this album is highly revered by Young fans and I like it too, but i just don't love it. I'd honestly rather listen to unplugged.

blastingas10

I think it's pretty damn good.

Stephen

This is a good album. He certainly proves more that capable of holding the audience unaccompanied. However, having heard most of the tracks elsewhere I'm not sure this album has enough to set itself apart from the rest of his catalogue. Some good, classic Neil that actually pre-dates many of the corresponding album versions but probably not a necessary addition for anyone who isn't an obsessive collector.

Lisnaholic

I`m not familiar with Unplugged, so I checked out the track list and a couple of songs, though I was a little disappointed. The album dips into material from right across Neil`s career, which makes it quite interesting, but it also settles for some reason on a few of his weaker songs, such as Long May You Run and Look Out For My Love. On the plus side, some songs are significantly reworked from their usual formats; Hurricane and Old Laughing Lady for example.

There are just two songs that turn up on both albums, Helpless and Needle and these illustrate what I particularly like about the Massey Hall album. Firstly there is Neil`s voice, pure and strong to bring out his trademark, poignant sound, and then there is the intimacy of the proceedings; the cheers when North Ontario is mentioned; the conversational intro to Needle, which was then a brand new song.

So I guess, I`m one of the fans revering Massey Hall; a collection of some of my favourite NY songs, faultlessly and simply presented by one man with just his guitar and piano, nowhere to hide. But then, bearing in mind what fazstp says, I`m only voting "Good", because let`s face it, forty years on, we`ve heard it all before thank you Neil !!

__________________
"Am I enjoying this moment? I know of it and perhaps that is enough." - Sybille Bedford, 1953

blastingas10

I agree. I think Massey Hall is better than unplugged. But I disagree when you say 'long may you run' is a weaker song, I think it's pretty good. I'm not a big fan of the unplugged version of 'helpless'

Lisnaholic

I wonder which tracks you particularly liked on Massey Hall ? I think the piano version of A Man Needs A Maid here is much better than the Harvest version. How about you ?

I guess I like NY best when he`s struggling to express sadness, like on Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere. For me, Long May You Run just isn`t depressing enough !!

__________________
"Am I enjoying this moment? I know of it and perhaps that is enough." - Sybille Bedford, 1953

blastingas10

Haha, Long May You Run hits a pretty sad note for me, but uplifting at the same time.

And I agree, the Massey Hall version of A Man Needs a Maid is really good.

I love the Massey Hall video footage.

Lisnaholic

^ I haven`t really seen any of that, except for the clip that Salami put somewhere.
Have you checked out any of the other NY archive albums ? Long May You Run turns up on Live On Air:The Lost Tapes, not that I`ve heard that album myself.

__________________
"Am I enjoying this moment? I know of it and perhaps that is enough." - Sybille Bedford, 1953

blastingas10

Just turned on this Neil Young tribute on vh1. It's a little more than halfway through. I thought John mellencamp's version of 'down by the river' was pretty bad, didnt like it at all. I really enjoyed Crosby, stills, and Nash's version of 'human highway'. Stephen stills never disappoints me when he plays guitar, he's damn good. Elton John, Leon Russell, t-bone burnett and Sheryl crow are playing 'helpless'. It's not bad but not great.